• Contact Sales
  • Resellers
  • Support
Yubico Header Text LogoYubico Header Text Logo
Why Yubicoexpand_more
Why Yubico
  • Enterprises
  • SMBs
  • Individuals
  • Developers
  • Careers
  • Partner programs
  • Affiliate program
  • Contact Sales
  • Events
  • Press room
  • Yubico Blog
  • Yubico Executive Connect
  • About us
  • The team
  • Investors
  • Innovation history
  • Secure it Forward
Man holding YubiKey
Easy-to-use, secure authentication

With YubiKey there’s no tradeoff between great security and usability

Why YubiKey
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Google headquarters
Proven at scale at Google

Google defends against account takeovers and reduces IT costs

Google Case Study
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Hand holding YubiKey behind Apple iPhone
Protecting vulnerable organizations

Secure it Forward: One YubiKey donated for every 20 sold

Learn about Secure it Forward
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Productsexpand_more
All products
  • YubiKey 5 Series
  • YubiKey 5 FIPS Series
  • YubiKey Bio Series
  • Security Key Series
  • YubiKey 5 CSPN Series
  • YubiHSM 2 & YubiHSM 2 FIPS
  • YubiEnterprise Subscription
  • YubiEnterprise Delivery
  • Yubico Authenticator
  • Computer login tools
  • Software Development Toolkits
  • YubiCloud
  • Using YubiKey is easy
  • Find the right YubiKey
  • Works with YubiKey
  • Compare YubiKeys
Woman holding YubiKey 5ci
One key for hundreds of apps and services

YubiKey works out-of-the-box and has no client software or battery

Yubico protects you
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
See YubiKeys as a Service
YubiEnterprise Subscription delivers scale and savings

Gain a future-proofed solution and faster MFA rollouts

See YubiKeys as a Service
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Solutionsexpand_more
Solutions overview
  • Zero Trust
  • Executive Order OMB M-22-09
  • Phishing-resistant MFA
  • Passwordless
  • Compliance
  • Cyber Insurance
  • Secure supply chain
  • Critical infrastructure
  • Hybrid & remote workers
  • Secure privileged users
  • Mobile restricted environments
  • Call centers
  • Shared workstations
  • Microsoft ecosystem
  • Salesforce workspace
  • IAM solutions
  • AWS environment
  • HYPR experience
Hand holding YubiKey behind Apple iPhone
The Bridge to Passwordless

Begin the journey to make your organization passwordless

Get the white paper
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Lock on a laptop
Accelerate your Zero Trust Strategy

7 best strong authentication practices to jumpstart your Zero Trust program

Get the white paper
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Government building
Federal cybersecurity requirements

See guidance for CIOs and leaders to prepare for the modern cyber threat era

Get the white paper
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Industriesexpand_more
Industries overview
  • High tech
  • Federal government
  • Federal systems integrators
  • State & local government
  • Education
  • Financial services
  • Elections & campaigns
  • Retail & hospitality
  • Telecommunications
  • Healthcare
  • Pharmaceuticals
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Energy & natural resources
  • Manufacturing
man working a manufacturing line
Manufacturing and supply chain security

Authentication best practices for manufacturing using highest-assurance security

Get the white paper
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Person looking at a computer with a government building showing
Phishing-resistant MFA: Fact vs. Fiction

Meet requirements for phishing-resistant MFA in OMB M-22-09 guidelines

Get the white paper
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Remote workers at a wind farm
Secure energy and natural resources from cyber threats

Best practices for phishing-resistant MFA to safeguard your critical infrastructure

Get the white paper
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Resourcesexpand_more
All resources
  • Yubico Blog
  • Cybersecurity glossary
  • Authentication standards
  • Resource library
  • Developer program
  • Product briefs
  • Solution briefs
  • Case studies
  • Get a pilot started
  • White papers and reports
  • Webinars
Laptop with a YubiKey inserted
BeyondTrust: secured with a subscription

A leader in Privileged Access Management simplifies YubiKey deployment

How they optimized ROI
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
S&P Global Market Intelligence report: old habits die hard

Only 46% of respondents protect their applications with MFA. How about you?

Read the report
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Considering Passkeys for your Enterprise?

Learn how to avoid the common pitfalls of synced passkeys

Get the Ebook
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Supportexpand_more
Support home
  • Find the right YubiKey
  • Set up your YubiKey
  • Downloads
  • Product documentation
  • Support articles
  • Support Services
  • Professional Services
  • YubiEnterprise Subscription
  • Works with YubiKey Program
  • Buying and shipping information
  • Security advisories
  • Help center
YubiKeys in lots of form factors
How to set up your YubiKey

Follow our guided tutorials to start protecting your favorite services

Set up your YubiKey
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
YubiKey on a keychain plugged into a laptop
Find the best YubiKey for your needs

Take the guided quiz and see which YubiKey best fits your or your businesses needs

Take the quiz
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
Worker with a calculator and laptop with a spreadsheet
Accelerate your YubiKey deployment

Technical and operational guidance for your YubiKey implementation and rollout

Professional Services
  • 2FA
  • authentication
  • FIDO2
  • MFA
  • passwordless
SubscribeStore
  • Home » Blog » In passwordless authentication, who is holding the keys?

    In passwordless authentication, who is holding the keys?

    David Treece

    David Treece

    November 18, 2021
    6 minute read
    Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare via Email

    Strong authentication practices are based on validating a number of authentication factors to a relying party (RP) or identity provider (IDP) to prove you are who the RP expects. Examples of relying parties could be Dropbox or Salesforce. Identity providers, who can also be a relying party that interacts with the authenticator, include Microsoft Azure, Okta, Duo Security and Ping Identity, amongst many others. 

    The factors commonly used are something you know, something you have, or something you are. Providing two of these factors provides a higher confidence of the user than just one. Two factor authentication (2FA) has become the standard practice and a requirement in many industries. The term multi-factor authentication (MFA) is also commonly used to describe the process of using more than one authentication factor for authentication. 

    Passwords, something you know, have traditionally been used to provide the initial “first” factor in a MFA flow. That MFA flow requires a second authentication, typically something you have, that may involve additional authentication vendors. The RP validates each authentication factor before allowing access. 

    Secure passwordless login ushers in a new way of thinking

    Modern strong authentication where passwords are no longer used, adheres to MFA principles but the process is different. It’s important to understand these differences to fully protect your systems. 

    Passwordless authentication, based on smart cards or FIDO2, fundamentally changes how 2FA is processed. In a passwordless model, the validation of the first factor and second factor shifts solely to the authenticator. Typically the first factor is physical possession of the authenticator itself, and the second factor is the PIN or a biometric validation to unlock the authenticator and perform the cryptographic operation.

    From a FIDO perspective, the authenticator controls the private key. The authenticator can be the smartphone’s secure enclave or trust zone, a computer’s TPM, or a YubiKey’s secure element. It is a vitally important job of the authenticator to ensure the private key is secured so it cannot be stolen or cloned. 

    Ensuring 2FA is being used and the authenticator is properly storing private key material

    Given that passwordless authentication shifts much of the authentication process to the authenticator, how do we know that 2FA is actually being used and that the authenticator is properly storing the private key material? 

    With the PIV smart card standard, the second factor is via the PIN that unlocks the smart card. FIDO2 authentication can optionally be used as a multi-factor cryptographic authenticator. Within FIDO2, user verification (UV) serves to ensure that the person authenticating to a service is in fact who they say they are for the purposes of the service and is in control of the private key credential. The user is authorized to verify their identity by entering a PIN or a biometric, like a fingerprint via a prompt on the client. The authenticator performs user verification and responds to the RP that UV was successful in a way that is cryptographically verifiable by the RP. When using a FIDO2 credential for the passwordless flow, UV needs to be set to “REQUIRED” and the IDP has to check for and enforce it.

    User Verification provides an important authentication factor but as mentioned above, the relying party does not have any visibility into the user verification process. The authenticator validates the user and informs the relying party of the UV action. The RP relies on the authenticator to properly handle the UV processing and return the appropriate response. While this reduces the overall MFA complexity, the relying party needs to trust that the authenticator is doing the authentication process securely. Following Zero Trust principles, how can the authenticator be verified as trustworthy?  

    What it means for an authenticator to be trustworthy

    In order to understand the security properties of an authenticator, relying parties should check device attestation statements. Attestation enables each relying party to use a cryptographically verified chain of trust from the device’s manufacturer so that access decisions can be made based on a risk profile. Attestation information should be captured so current and future decisions can be made, up to and including blocking, if issues arise. The attestation keys are set at manufacturing time and cannot be altered or exported. Attestation provides assurance of the properties of the authenticator as stated by the manufacturer. Attestation is a powerful tool to provide additional assurance that the authenticator is a valid authentication product from a trusted manufacturer. Not all authenticator device manufacturers support attestation across the different authentication protocols. In addition, each platform that has a built-in authenticator may handle attestation differently. It is important to understand how each device and manufacturer implements attestation to take advantage of this security control. Yubico has clear guidance on how to implement attestation for the protocols that generate asymmetric keypairs on the device such as WebAuthn, PIV, and PGP.    

    The authenticator needs to ensure that processes it performs are secure and key material cannot be copied off the device. If it can be, a cloned authenticator could be developed and used to authenticate. The authenticator manufacturer needs to adhere to security best practices to ensure credentials cannot be extracted. You can learn more about how Yubico performs secure manufacturing here. 

    Passwordless Authentication Summary

    From the beginning of computers, something you know (a password) has been the primary factor and our mindset has been around securing what you know. That is no longer the case when we transition to a passwordless world. The industry has shifted to something you have as being the most important factor whether it be your PC, phone, or YubiKey. The shift has occurred due to the fact that something you have is usually harder to compromise than something you know. Additionally, the industry has matured to support hardware backed authentication that works natively within browsers and operating systems.   

    But when the industry shifts so do the attackers. Hardware backed passwordless authentication is significantly more secure than legacy forms of authentication, but security professionals still need to be aware of the potential attack vectors. Whether a company realizes it or not, something the user has is the most important factor, and the other factors are designed to secure what you have. As you implement passwordless authentication, security controls and models need to focus on this reality compared to just relying on traditional approaches that are no longer sufficient.

    Read Yubico’s Bridge to Passwordless series to learn more about how to plan and execute a passwordless strategy.

    Share this article:

    Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare via Email

    Recommended Posts

    • Q&A with CEO Mattias Danielsson: Yubico’s next stage of growth as a public company and what investors can expect

      Today marks an exciting, historic day in Yubico’s history: the company is now publicly traded under the ticker symbol YUBICO on Nasdaq First Growth North Market in Stockholm. As the cyber threat landscape continues to evolve rapidly through increasingly sophisticated attacks like phishing, the need for phishing-resistant MFA with the YubiKey are at an all-time […]

      Read more
      • Investors
      • Q&A
      • thought leadership
    • Five foundational cybersecurity controls to mitigate 90% of breaches

      During my 16 years in the cybersecurity industry, and after discussions with numerous CISOs and cyber security experts, they all agree that there are five easy steps all organizations can take to mitigate over 90% of all cyber breaches1.  Just like cars were not initially designed for safety, the internet was not designed for security. […]

      Read more
      • best practice guide
    • Okta + Yubico: Better together

      Modern cybersecurity needs to be phishing-resistant, but it also needs to incorporate a great user experience for employees, IT teams and customers. We know traditional authentication methods are perceived as user-friendly, but they are not secure and vulnerable to most attacks  – in fact, 59% of people still rely on username and password to authenticate […]

      Read more
      • Okta
      • Partner Program
    • Works with YubiKey Spotlight: How Yubico works with industry leaders who share the commitment to strong authentication

      As the cyber threat landscape continues to evolve rapidly in the form of more sophisticated attacks like phishing and ransomware, the need for industry collaborations and partnerships are more critical than ever to help businesses and consumers stay secure online. We first launched the Works with YubiKey (WWYK) program in 2018 with this in mind […]

      Read more
      • Works with YubiKey
      • wwyk
Yubico Text LogoYubico Text Logo
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • GitHub
  • Product finder quiz
  • Find set-up guides
  • Buy online
  • Contact sales
  • Get Yubico updates
  • Careers
  • Events
  • Press room
  • About us
  • Investors
  • Partner programs
  • Affiliate program
  • YubiKey 5 Series
  • YubiKey 5 FIPS Series
  • YubiKey Bio Series
  • Security Key Series
  • YubiKey 5 CSPN Series
  • YubiHSM 2 & YubiHSM 2 FIPS
  • Yubico Authenticator
  • Zero Trust
  • Phishing-resistant MFA
  • Passwordless
  • Cyber insurance
  • More solutions
  • Industries overview
  • Yubico blog
  • Resource library
  • Cybersecurity glossary
  • Authentication standards
  • Developer program
  • Works with YubiKey
  • Help center
  • Downloads
  • Product documentation
  • Support Services
  • Professional Services
  • Contact support
Yubico © 2023 All Rights Reserved.
  • Sitemap
  • Cookies
  • Legal
  • Privacy
  • Patents
  • Terms of use
  • Trust