Alessio Di Mauro

Does Key Size Really Matter in Cryptography?

One of the most interesting and useful aspects of the YubiKey NEO and NEO-n is that they can act as a smart card and come pre-loaded with a bunch of interesting applications, such as an implementation of OpenPGP Card.

Many end-users like this functionality, but some question the key lengths. It’s an expected cryptographic question and is worth examining in some detail. I will walk you through it with a series of three blogs I will publish this week. Today is the first installment.crypto bug

OpenPGP is a standard that allows users to encrypt, decrypt, sign and authenticate data. It is an open standardized variant of PGP, available as a FOSS implementation in the form GNU Privacy Guard (GPG) and is most notably used for email encryption and authentication. Independent of the actual implementation, OpenPGP (and PGP) supports both symmetric and asymmetric cryptography. Today we will focus on the latter.

Simplified cryptography primer

To better understand what follows, a few very basic concepts of cryptography are required. In asymmetric or public-key encryption there are two main players: the encryption algorithm itself (RSA, ECC, ElGamal, …) and a cryptographic key pair. (There are also encryption/signature schemes such as PKCS#1, ECDSA and ECDH, but that is another discussion).

Each encryption algorithm is based on a computationally-hard problem. The mathematical transformation constitutes the operation that the encryption scheme can perform,  encrypt/decrypt, whereas the keys provide the additional data. A similar statement can be made for signature algorithms where the operations are sign/ verify.

The two keys of a same key pair are strongly interconnected, this is a fundamental property of asymmetric cryptography. The keys must be used together to achieve different properties such as confidentiality, authenticity and integrity.

Confidentiality is a guarantee the message is received only by the intended recipients. Authenticity guarantees the identity of the author, and integrity confirms both confidentiality and authenticity by ensuring that a message has not been modified in transit. (Click here for a brief introduction to cryptography)

On to PGP

All this can be achieved if, and only if, the secret key of a user remains uncompromised. However, not all keys are created equal.

In computer security, the length of a cryptographic key is defined by its length measured in number of bits, rather than being connected to the number and shape of its ridges and notches like in a physical key (say for your car). Provided that an encryption algorithm actually supports different key lengths, the general rule is that the longer the key, the better.

In the next installment, we’ll look at suitable key lengths and how they compare. In a third installment, we will take on the 2048 vs 4096 key length debate then examine chip-based characteristics that define today’s YubiKey cryptography. And then wrap-up by looking at what Yubico has in the lab and how we plan to move forward. See you tomorrow.

Part 2: Comparing Asymmetric Encryption Algorithms
Part 3: The big debate, 2048 vs. 4096, Yubico’s stand

Comments are closed.